Fall Forum Speaker Presentations....

photo of Fall Forum 2022

The Phoenix Chapter of the Appraisal Institute held its its annual Fall Forum, (interrupted a couple of years because of COVID), on Thursday November 10, 2022 at the Desert Willow in Phoenix.   This event was a full day (in-person), meeting with a variety of speakers covering topics of interest to appraisers.  Our keynote speak was Rick Merritt, President of Elliott D. Pollack & Company, who spoke about the economy in Arizona.    Ned Chappell, MAI, CAE and current Litigation Supervisor of the Maricopa County Assessor's Office, was our Master of Cerimonies. 

Each speaker gave a presentation, complete with PowerPoint slides.  Those speakers who agreed to allow distribution of their PowerPoint presenations can find them by clicking on the link that has their name, (see below).    

The Fall Forum will provided 7.0 hours of Continuing Education credit for Arizona appraisers. The forum included a continental breakfast, lunch, drinks and snacks throughout the day.   This event, which keeps getting better every year, was organized by PCAI Education Committee co-chars Steve MacDonald, MAI, SRA, and Kevin Neal, MAI.  

If you have questions about the Fall Forum or any PCAI activity, please contact Jenny at aiphoenix152@gmail.com


John Wyatt Finishes Two Year Term

photo of Jim Driskill and John Wyatt

John Wyatt, MAI is in the process of finishing his two year term as President of the Phoenix Chapter of the Appraisal Institute.   John was awarded a plaque at the Fall Forum by incoming President Jim Driskill, MAI SRA.  

By the Numbers - As of November 2022, the chapter currently has 96 Designated Members, of which 8 are life members, 4 are semi-retired, 26 are Designated as residential.  We have 28 Candidates, and 27 Practicing Affiliates. i

Looking to serve your Chapter and network some more? Look no further. PCAI needs members to serve on the following committees. 

Nomination Committee (helps facilitate annual chapter elections by seeking qualified candidates)

Education Committee (if you want to provide your input on classes that you feel should be offered by the Chapter - this is the committee for you).

Candidate Guidance Committee (looking to give back your time to assist PCAI members in getting their Designation? This is the committee for that).

If you are interested in any of these positions, please reach out to the Chapter office at: aiphoenix152@gmail.com


Cactus photo of the phoenix business district

Jeannie Beaff Retires

Jeannie Beaff, long time Phoenix Chapter of the Appraisal Institute administator of 30 years, retired as of the end of November, 2021. 

A retirement gathering was held Thursday, December 9th, 2021 at the Pedal Haus Brewery in Tempe, and was well attended.  

All member of the Phoenix Chapter of the Appraisal Institute wish Jeannie the best as she moves forward with a new chapter in her life.

Jeannie has been replaced by Jenny Calabrese, who will act as the the Executive Director for the Phoenix Chapter of the Appraisal Institute going forward.  Jenny is experienced at keeping chapters in compliance with Appraisal Institute rules, proceedures and guidelines, as she also serves as the Executive Director of the Sacramento Chapter of A.I.  


Cactus photo of the phoenix business district

2021 Annual Conference

The Appraisal Institute 2021 Annual Conference was held in Orlando, Florida from August 7 - 11 at the JW Marriott Grande Lakes.

A.I. President Rodman Schley, MAI SRA opened the meeting and noted that the residential appraisal community is under fire, in particular from the Brookings Institute. The Brookings Institute believes that appraisals, along with lending practices, zoning, and real estate agent behavior, often have racial bias, which contributes to low value for homes owned by Black Americans

One “solution” that is being floated is to do away with the sales comparison approach, and rely on the cost approach instead. Most appraiser’s will understand that this solution is flawed, and point out that the cost approach requires an estimate of land value, which is usually itself obtained from sales comparison. The approach also requires the consideration of physical, functional, and external obsolescence. In theory, a well executed sales comparison approach and a well executed cost approach should result in the same value. These facts about basic methodologies used by appraisers may be unknown to advocates of the Brookings Institute study. (Or more concerning, they may not want to know).

None-the-less, the Appraisal Institute recognizes that unconscious bias does exist, and has plans for programs that reinforce ethics, education, and training, with an additional effort to recruit more diverse appraisers. A.I. is developing a 7 hour unconscious bias course, and will update A.I.’s Code of Professional Ethics, along with Co-hosting seminars with the Brookings Institute.

On April 20, 2021 the US House Financial Services Committee approved HR 2553, the Real Estate Valuation Fairness and Improvement Act. This new legislation would establish a task force to study underwriting standards, and provide resources to promote diversity within the valuation profession, among other things. The act has the potential to greatly impact the day to day operations of appraisers.

Conventional wisdom says that it is always better to be at the table rather than be on the menu. As such, in March 20201 Rodman Schley wrote a letter on behalf of the Appraisal Institute to Maxine Waters, Chairman of the House Committee on Financial Services. In the letter Rodman supported the legislation, and encouraged the development of flexibility in mortgage underwriting, including allowing appraisers to consider sales in other geographic markets with similar housing stock, and consider a range of value for a property rather than a single point.

MISMO Standards for Commercial Appraisals

In March of 2010, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required the submission of residential appraisals in UAD format, (Uniform Appraisal Dataset). The UAD was an effort to standardize formats for certain fields, (dates, values, condition and quality ratings, etc). Once standardized, these UAD appraisals were then submitted to electronic portals using an XML file format. The XML file format was the brain child of the Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization, (MISMO). MISMO is an effort by the financial services industry to digitize loans.

These additional appraisal burdens no longer apply only to residential appraisers. According to A.I.’s Legislation & Regulatory Update, the MISMO organization has approved a commercial appraisal dataset as of June, 2021. As such it is likely that banks and other lenders soon will require commercial appraisers to provide portions of their work product in electronic form, a form that allows their data to be scraped and traded among lenders and GSE’s (just like residential appraisers have had to do for many years).

In summary, the valuation industry, and the appraisers who work there, are going to be impacted by coming changes. In 1963 Leon Megginson summarized Darwin’s Origin of the Species and wrote, “It is not the most intellectual of the species that survives; it is not the strongest that survives; but the species that survives is one that is best able to adapt and adjust to the changing environment in which it finds itself”. To survive, appraisers are going to have to change. Again.

AI Education & Relief Foundation

Since 2005, the Appraisal Institute Education and Relief Foundation (AIERF) has provided more than $300,000 in emergency financial assistance to Appraisal Institute and other real estate professionals in need. While this continues to be a challenging time for many of us, AIERF remains committed to serving and supporting our community no matter the professional obstacles we face.

If you or someone you know has experienced a disaster or emergency causing financial, physical, or emotional distress, please apply today.

The assistance provided by AIERF is made possible through the generous support of individuals within the real estate appraisal profession. Your donations assist colleagues in need, support scholarships for aspiring appraisers, and contribute to the advancement of the appraisal profession overall.

If you are able to, please consider a donation today.

Coronavirus (COVID-19)

As the Appraisal Institute continues to monitor guidance from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Health Organization, AI is taking seriously the health, safety and well-being of its professionals, customers and staff during the coronavirus pandemic.

In this fluid environment, the Appraisal Institute encourages its professionals to remain aware of developments and resources offered by health professionals and public health organizations and to respond accordingly.

Additionally, here is some guidance cultivated by AI Professional Practice staff:

Additional Appraisal Institute resources, with an extensive list of list of Federal and Agency Covid information, can be found here.